判识水氡地震前兆的方法——以甘肃清水温泉水氡异常为例

doi:10.12196/j.issn.1000-3274.2020.04.016

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 地震前兆异常性质的准确判断是提高地震预测水平的前提。据国内外相关统计, 真正具有地震预测意义的地震前兆异常数量十分有限。因此, 厘清震前异常与地震的关系对今后异常识别意义重大。 2017年8月8日九寨沟M_S7.0地震前4个月, 甘肃清水温泉水氡出现大幅波动异常变化。为了判断这次异常与九寨沟地震的关系, 在异常持续期间, 通过抽水实验、水化学组分以及氢氧同位素组成分析, 并结合九寨沟地震发震构造以及其他前兆异常空间分布特征, 对水氡异常成因机理进行了深入分析。结果表明: 对于水氡与水位的变化关系, 实验与实际观测结果一致, 都呈正相关变化; 实验中水氡变化幅度与实际观测的相当; 水化学组分以及氢氧同位素测试结果显示清水温泉水氡异常期间, 来自地壳深部的流体并未增加; 清水温泉区其他前兆没有出现明显的短期异常变化; 在空间上清水温泉与九寨沟地震震源区被两条深大断裂隔开。因此, 清水温泉水氡大幅异常变化并非九寨沟地震的短期前兆异常, 而是企业抽水开始时间、持续时间以及用水量不固定引起的。该实例为地震前流体前兆异常性质的准确判定提供了更为可靠的方法和思路。

关键词: 九寨沟地震, 清水温泉水氡, 抽水实验, 水化学组分, 氢氧同位素

Abstract: Correct judgements for anomaly features is the precondition for enhancing our ability to do the earthquake prediction. According to relative statistic, the true anomalies of earthquake are quite limited. It is important to study the relationship between the precursors and following earthquakes. The radon of Qingshui hot spring fluctuated drastically the 4th month before Jiuzhaigou M_S7.0 earthquake on August 8, 2017. In order to identify the relationship between the radon anomaly and the earthquake, the cause and mechanism of this radon anomaly were studied deeply by pumping tests, analyzing isotopes and hydrochemistry components of Qingshui hot spring.The seismogenic structure of Jiuzhaigou earthquake and some other anomalies were also analyzed. The results showed that the test results are consistent with the actual observation. The water radon variation is positively correlated with water level variation but with water temperature.The proportion of fluid from deep crust did not increase according to composition of hydrogen and oxygen isotope and hydrochemistry. There seems to be little probability of seismogenic process of Jiuzhaigou earthquake caused rupture of Qingshui hot spring area.The radon anomalous of Qingshui hot spring is not the short-term anomaly for the 2017 Jiuzhaigou M_S7.0 earthquake. It was caused by manual pumping. This study provides a more reliable method for identifying the anomalies of fluid before earthquakes.

Key words: The 2017 Jiuzhaigou M_S7.0 earthquake, Water radon of Qingshui hot spring, Pumping test, Hydrochemical components, Hydrogen and oxygen isotope

中图分类号:

P315.7

苏鹤军, 曹玲玲, 张慧, 李晨桦, 周慧玲. 判识水氡地震前兆的方法——以甘肃清水温泉水氡异常为例[J]. 地震, 2020, 40(4): 198-213.

SU He-jun, CAO Ling-ling, ZHANG Hui, LI Chen-hua, ZHOU Hui-ling. The Method for Identify the Earthquake Precursor of Water RadonTaking the Water Radon Anomaly of Qingshui Hot Spring in Gansu Province As an Example[J]. EARTHQUAKE, 2020, 40(4): 198-213.

参考文献

[1] 易桂喜, 龙锋, 梁明剑, 等. 2017年8月8日九寨沟M7.0地震及余震震源机制解与发震构造分析[J]. 地球物理学报, 2017, 60(10): 4083-4097.
YI Gui-xi, LONG Feng, LIANG Ming-jian, et al. Focal mechanism solutions and seismogenic structure of the 8 August 2017 M7.0 Jiuzhaigou earthquake and its aftershocks, northern Sichuan[J]. Chinese Jouranal of Geophysics, 60(1): 4083-4097 (in Chinese).
[2] 戴岚欣, 许强, 范宣梅, 等. 2017年8月8日四川九寨沟地震诱发地质灾害空间分布规律及易发性评价初步研究[J]. 工程地质学报, 2017, 25(4): 1151-1164.
DAI Lan-xin, XU Qiang, FAN Xuan-mei, et al. A preliminary study on spatial distribution patterns of landslides triggered by Jiuzhaigou earthquake in Sichuan on august 8th, 2017 and their susceptibility assessment [J]. Journal of Engineering Geology, 2017, 25(4): 1151-1164 (in Chinese).
[3] Tohjima Y, Igarashi G, Wakita H. Variations in ground-water flow rate at the KSM well, a most sensitive well to earthquake occurrences[J]. Journal of Physics of the Earth, 1994, 42(3): 221-235.
[4] 刘杰, 张国民. “是否存在有助于预报的地震前兆”的讨论[J]. 科学通报, 2016, 61(18): 1988-1994.
LIU Jie, ZHANG Guo-min. Discussion on “Are there earthquake precursors that can lead to useful predictions?”[J]. Chinese Science Bulletin, 2016, 61(18): 1988-1994 (in Chinese).
[5] 简春林. 中国大陆地震地下流体异常特征研究[J]. 地震, 2004, 24(1): 42-49.
JIAN Chun-lin. Research on underground fluid anomaly characteristics of seismicity in China’s continent[J]. Earthquake, 2004, 24(1): 42-49 (in Chinese).
[6] 岳明生. 地震预测研究发展战略的几点思考[J]. 国际地震动态, 2005, (5): 7-21.
YUE Ming-sheng. Thoughts about the strategy for the development of earthquake prediction[J]. Recent Development in World Seismology, 2005, (5): 7-21 (in Chinese).
[7] 车用太, 鱼金子. 地震地下流体学[M]. 北京: 气象出版社, 2006.
CHE Yong-tai, YU Jin-zi. Underground fluids and earthquake[M]. Beijing: China Meteorological Press, 2006 (in Chinese).
[8] 车用太, 刘成龙, 鱼金子, 等. 汶川M_S8.0地震的地下流体与宏观异常及地震预测问题的思考[J]. 地震地质, 2008, 30(4): 828-838.
CHE Yong-tai, LIU Cheng-long, YU Jin-zi, et al. Underground fluid anomaly and macro anomaly of M_S8.0 Wenchuan earthquake and opinions about earthquake prediction[J]. Seismology and Geology, 2008, 30(4): 828-838 (in Chinese).
[9] 晏锐, 田雷, 王广才, 等. 2008年汶川8.0级地震前地下流体异常回顾与统计特征分析[J]. 地球物理学报, 2018, 61(5): 1907-1921.
YAN Rui, TIAN Lei, WANG Guang-cai, et al. Review and statistically characteristic analysis of underground fluid anomalies prior to the 2008 Wenchuan M_S8.0 earthquake[J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics, 2018, 61(5): 1907-1321 (in Chinese).
[10] 杜芳, 蒋海昆, 杨马陵, 等. 中国震例—2008年5月12日四川汶川8.0级地震[M]. 北京: 地震出版社, 2018.
DU Fang, JIANG Hai-kun, YANG Ma-ling, et al. M_S8.0 Wenchuan earthquake in Sichuan on May 12, 2008[M]. Beijing: Seismological Press, 2018 (in Chinese).
[11] 刘成龙, 车用太, 吕金波. 京北地热田开发对地下流体动态的影响[J]. 地震地质, 2006, 28(1): 142-149.
LIU Cheng-long, CHE Yong-tai, L Jin-bo. Influence on Jingbei geothermal field exploitation on subsurface fluid behaviors[J]. Seismology and Geology, 2006, 28(1): 142-149 (in Chinese).
[12] 刘学领, 马建英, 李一兵. 地热开发对王3、王4井水化学动态的影响及其成因分析[J]. 地震地质, 2009, 31(3): 526-535.
LIU Xue-ling, MA Jian-ying, LI Yi-bing. Analysis on effect and cause of water chemistry behavior in Wang-3 and Wang-4 wells due to geothermal exploitation[J]. Seismology and Geology, 2009, 31(3): 526-535 (in Chinese).
[13] 宋晓冰, 张常慧, 李海孝, 等. 热水开采对怀来4井氡的影响及对策[J]. 地震地磁观测与研究, 2007, 28(3): 67-69.
SONG Xiao-bing, ZHANG Chang-hui, LI Hai-xiao, et al. The influences and countermeasures of the hot water extracting to radon measures in well #4 of Huailai[J]. Seismological and Geomagnetic Observation and Research, 2007, 28(3): 67-69 (in Chinese).
[14] 张守训, 李百祥. 天水及其南北地区温泉分布的地质-地球物理特征[J]. 西北地震学报, 2006, 28(3): 252-257.
ZHANG Shou-xun, LI Bai-xiang. The geological and geophysical characteristics of hot spring distribution in Tianshui and its NS adjacent areas[J]. Northwestern Seismological Journal, 2006, 28(3): 252-257 (in Chinese).
[15] 吕超甲, 刘雷, 周晓成, 等. 甘肃东南地区温泉流体地球化学特征[J]. 地震, 2017, 37(1): 52-60.
LU Chao-jia, LIU Lei, ZHOU Xiao-cheng, et al. Geochemical characteristics of hot spring fluid in the southeastern Gansu Province[J]. Earthquake, 2017, 37(1): 52-60 (in Chinese).
[16] 蒋凤亮, 李桂茹, 王基华, 等. 地震地球化学[M]. 北京: 地震出版社, 1989 .
JIANG Feng-liang, LI Gui-ru, WANG Ji-hua, et al. Seismological geochemistry [M]. Beijing: Seismological Press, 1989 (in Chinese).
[17] Gemici , Taracan G. Hydrogeochemistry of the Simav geothermal field, western Anatolia, Turkey[J]. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermai Research, 2002, 116(3): 215-233.
[18] 何丹, 马致远, 王疆霞, 等. 关中盆地深部地下热水残存沉积水的同位素证据[J]. 地球科学与环境学报, 2014, 36(4): 117-126.
HE Dan, MA Zhi-yuan, WANG Jiang-xia, et al. Isotopic evidence of remaining sedimentary water in the deep geothermal water of Guanzhong basin[J]. Journal of Earth Science and Environment, 2014, 36(4): 117-126 (in Chinese).
[19] Giggenbach W F. Geothermal solute equilibria. Derivation of Na-K-Mg-Ca geoindicators[J]. Geochimical Et Cosmochimica Atca, 1988, 52(12): 2749-2765.
[20] 张磊, 刘耀炜, 任宏微, 等. 水化学分析方法在地下水异常核实中的应用[J]. 地震, 2019, 39(1): 29-38.
ZHANG Lei, LIU Yao-wei, REN Hong-wei, et al. Application of hydrochemistry to the verification of groundwater anomalies[J]. Earthquake, 2019, 39(1): 29-38 (in Chinese).
[21] Kristiasson K, Malmqvist L. Evidence for nondiffusive transport of Rn in the ground and a new physical model for the transport[J]. Geophysics, 1982, 47(10): 1444-1452.
[22] Craig H. Isotope variations in meteoric water[J]. Science, 1961, 133(3465): 1702-1703.
[23] 郑淑蕙, 侯发高, 倪葆龄. 我国大气降水的氢氧稳定同位素研究[J]. 科学通报, 1983, (13): 801-806.
ZHENG Shu-hui, HOU Fa-gao, NI Bao-ling. Research of stable isotope in precipitation in China[J]. Chinese Science Bulletin, 1983, (13): 801-806 (in Chinese).
[24] 钱会, 马致远. 水文地球化学[M]. 北京: 地质出版社, 2005.
QIAN Hui, MA Zhi-yuan. Hydrogeochemistry[M]. Beijing: Geological Publishing House, 2005 (in Chinese).
[25] 邵志刚, 王芃. 2008年汶川8.0级地震对地震预测研究的启示思考[J]. 地震, 2018, 38(2): 1-10.
SHAO Zhi-gang, WANG Peng. Reflections on earthquake prediction research ten years after the 2008 Wenchuan M_S8.0 earthquake[J]. Earthquake, 2018, 38(2): 1-10 (in Chinese).
[26] 梅世蓉. 地震前兆场物理模式及前兆时空分布机制研究(二)强震孕育时应力、应变场的演化与地震活动、地震前兆的关系[J]. 地震学报, 1996, 18(1): 1-10.
MEI Shi-rong. Study on the physical model of earthquake precursory field and the mechanism of spatial-temporal distribution of precursory (2nd)The relationship among the evolution of stress, strain fields and seismicity and earthquake precursors during the preparation of strong earthquakes[J]. Acta Seismologica Sinica, 1996, 18(1): 1-10 (in Chinese).
[27] 安艳茹, 苏金蓉, 薛艳, 等. 2017年四川九寨沟M_S7.0地震的地震学特征[J]. 科学通报, 2018, 63(7): 663-673.
AN Yan-ru, SU Jin-rong, XUE Yan, et al. Seismological characteristic of the 2017, M_S7.0 Jiuzhaigou earthquake, Sichuan, China[J]. Chinese Science Bulletin, 2018, 63(7): 663-673 (in Chinese).
[28] 陈长云, 任金卫, 孟国杰, 等. 巴颜喀拉块体东部活动块体的划分、形变特征及构造意义[J]. 地球物理学报, 2013, 56(12): 4125-4141.
CHEN Chang-yun, REN Jin-wei, MENG Guo-jie, et al. Division, deformation and tectonic implication of active blocks in the eastern segment of Bayan Har block[J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics, 2013, 56(12): 4125-4141 (in Chinese).
[29] 邓起东, 高翔, 陈桂华, 等. 青藏高原昆仑—汶川地震系列与巴颜喀喇断块的最新活动[J]. 地学前缘, 2010, 17(5): 163-178.
DENG Qi-dong, GAO Xiang, CHEN Gui-hua, et al. Recent tectonic activity of Bayankala fault-block and Kunlun—Wenchuan earthquake series of the Tibetan plateau[J]. Earth Science Frontiers, 2010, 17(5): 163-178 (in Chinese).
[30] 张培震, 王敏, 甘卫军, 等. GPS观测的活动断裂滑动速率及其对现今大陆动力作用的制约[J]. 地学前缘, 2003, 10(S1): 81-91.
ZHAGN Pei-zhen, WANG Min, GAN Wei-jun, et al. Slip rates along major active faults from GPS measurements and constraints on contemporary continental tectonics[J]. Earth Science Frontiers, 2003, 10(S1): 81-91 (in Chinese).
[31] 袁道阳. 青藏高原东北缘晚新生代以来的构造变形特征与时空演化[D]. 北京: 中国地震局地质研究所, 2003.
YUAN Dao-yang. Tectonic deformation features and space-time evolution in northeastern margin of the Qinghai—Tibetan plateau since the late Cenozoic time[D]. Beijing: Institute of Geology, China Earthquake Administration, 2003 (in Chinese).
[32] 祝意青, 梁伟锋, 徐云马, 等. 汶川M_s8.0地震前后的重力场动态变化[J]. 地震学报, 2010, 32(6): 633-640.
ZHU Yi-qing, LIANG Wei-feng, XU Yun-ma, et al. Dynamic variation of gravity field before and after Wenchuan M_S8.0 earthquake[J]. Acta Seismological Sinica, 2010, 32(6): 633-640 (in Chinese).
[33] 张永仙, 石耀霖, 刘桂萍. 热物质上涌与震前重力异常关系初探[J]. 地震, 2000, 20(S1): 135-142.
ZHAG Yong-xian, SHI Yao-lin, LIU Gui-ping, et al. Preliminary study on the relationship between upwelling of hot material and gravity anomaly before earthquake[J]. Earthquake, 2000, 20(S1): 135-142 (in Chinese).
[34] 中国地震局地质研究所. 地震监测预报的新思路和新方法[M]∥车用太, 鱼金子, 高维安. 唐山地震前兆形成与演化的坚固体膨胀-热物质涌落(DR)模式. 北京: 地震出版社, 1997: 10-23.
Institute of Geology, China Earthquake Administration. New ideas and methods of earthquake monitoring and prediction[M]∥CHE Yong-tai, YU Jin-zi, GAO Wei-an. The DR model for the formation and evolution of Tangshan Earthquake precursors. Beijing: Seismological Press, 1997: 10-23 (in Chinese).
[35] 马宗晋, 傅征祥, 张郢珍, 等. 1966~1976年中国九大地震[M]. 北京: 地震出版社, 1982.
MA Zong-jin, FU Zheng-xiang, ZHANG Ying-zhen, et al. Nine strong earthquakes in China between 1966~1976[M]. Beijing: Seismological Press, 1982 (in Chinese).
[36] 王武星, 梁明. GRACE观测的区域重力场变化与大地震关系探讨[J]. 地震, 2018, 38(2): 84-94.
WANG Wu-xing, LIANG Ming. Regional gravity changes associated with several large earthquake by GRACE[J]. Earthquake, 2018, 38(2): 84-94 (in Chinese).
[37] 祝意青, 梁伟锋, 赵云峰, 等. 2017年四川九寨沟M_S7.0地震前区域重力场变化[J]. 地球物理学报, 2017, 60(10): 4124-4131.
ZHU Yi-qing, LIANG Wei-feng, ZHAO Yun-feng, et al. Gravity changes before the Jiuzhaigou, Sichuan, M_S7.0 earthquake of 2017[J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics, 2017, 60(10): 4124-4131 (in Chinese).
[38] 杜建国, 李营, 王传远, 等. 高压地球科学[M]. 北京: 地震出版社, 2010.
DU Jian-guo, LI Ying, WANG Chuan-yuan, et al. High pressure geoscience[M]. Beijing: Seismological Press, 2010 (in Chinese).
[39] 杜建国, 仵柯田, 孙凤霞. 地震成因综述[J]. 地学前缘, 2018, 25(4): 255-267.
DU Jian-guo, WU Ke-tian, SUN Feng-xia. Earthquake generationg: a review[J]. Earthquake Science Frontiers, 2018, 25(4): 255-267 (in Chinese).
[40] 刘耀炜, 任宏微. 汶川8.0级地震氡观测值震后效应特征初步分析[J]. 地震, 2009, 29(1): 121-131.
LIU Yao-wei, REN Hong-wei. Preliminary analysis of the characteristics of post-seismic effect of radon after the Wenchuan 8.0 earthquake[J]. Earthquake, 2009, 29(1): 121-131 (in Chinese).
[41] 中国地震局监测预报司. 地震前兆异常落实工作指南[M]. 北京: 地震出版社, 2000.
Department of earthquake monitoring and prediction of China Earthquake Administration. Guidelines for the implementation of earthquake precursor anomalies[M]. Beijing: Seismological Press, 2000 (in Chinese).